Media Narratives Diverge from Reality
Television news media covers a variety of stories. Sometimes, these stories involve crimes or judicial activity related to crime. Presently, there have been several high profile trials in state courts. According to the textbook, “how the media frame these political issues and depict the people largely determines what the audience perceives” (Graber and Dunaway 2018). The news coverage of these stories drive a particular narrative. This narrative attracts the audience's attention by playing on emotions to stimulate various responses. The ultimate goal is to attract the attention of the audience. Information that supports the particular media narrative is included in the coverage. On the other hand, information that does not support the narrative is sometimes excluded. What is important to the media is the narrative they are presenting, not necessarily the facts and reality. Graber and Dunaway explain, “partisan media may provide different accounts of events and political issues as part of their partisan spin. In doing so, they may fail to provide full or accurate information and distort the knowledge of their audiences” (2018). In relation to these high profile trials in various courts around the country, what is presented in court may diverge from the media narrative. Evidence and witness testimony presented before the jury, during a trial, help shine a light on the true facts of the case or story. Since the media narrative drives people's attitudes and behaviors, it is important if possible to view the actual trial. As the evidence is presented and witnesses are questioned by attorneys, attitudes about the events may change dramatically. The trial is not a news story, but rather a platform where real information and facts can be exposed and presented.
Refrence
Graber, Doris A., and Johanna Dunaway. 2018. Mass Media and American Politics. Thousand Oaks, CA: CQ Press.
I really enjoyed your post. I like your take on the influence of the media and political views on court trials. I had never considered how the media's political agenda might impact a court case, but it makes sense. The media controls our understanding and, potentially our views, on everything from politics to the weather to other major events. Each media outlet has the ability to narrate a story however they want, whether or not it is an accurate representation of reality. Like you said, the media has the ability to manipulate how we see, understand, and behave in our world, and most of the time we aren't even aware it's happening. This is definitely made easier by consumers willingness to only consume media that aligns with their world view or political views. Sometimes it can be difficult for your everyday media consumer to find accurate and unbiased information. At least with trials, the truth always comes out.
ReplyDeleteYou can definitely see the differences in how both sides view court cases when it happens. It seems like both sides have their own interpretations of events despite many people not getting their sources first hand and getting them from some political pundit on their favorite channel. Even with things like this, people prefer to be told what to think than to put in the work to interpret it for themselves. There are key things that people differ on, because they refuse to look at the other side, even when both sides may be stretching the truth, or leaving out facts related to the other side.
ReplyDeleteThis is a super thought provoking post! When you mentioned the importance of viewing the trial itself, I really appreciated that. Much of what the general public receives, especially in high profile cases, are the dramatized and sensationalized reporting of a select few people when it actuality the trial was probably much more subdued with evidence being presented to allow for careful deliberation. When the media reports on cases, the deliberation is already done and does not allow much wiggle room for changing of minds. I enjoyed this post alot!
ReplyDelete