The Media as Policy Makers
Private corporate media companies have a great deal of influence over policy issues. These media companies conduct almost all the presidential debates. During the debates, the media had a lot of control over the questions being asked and how the issues were framed for the candidates. Graber and Dunaway explain, “the media can shape political action by ‘framing’-- reporting the news from a particular perspective, so that some aspects of the situation come into close focus and others fade into the background” (2018). During the last election cycle, the issue of healthcare was prominent in the political debate. Media personalities, who are strongly influenced by special interests, act as virtual policy makers during these debates. Questions to cast Medicare For All into a negative light dominate the healthcare issue portion of the debates. The negative questions asking “how are you going to pay for it”, and “will you increase taxes to pay for it” are repeated time and time again. The interests of for-profit health insurance companies are protected through the design of questioning of the candidates. The moderator does not ask “would you rather send your tax dollars to the useless/over expensive projects within the military industrial complex, or to the healthcare industry”. Instead they keep repeating how everyone's taxes will be raised to pay for it. They neglect to remind viewers that they would no longer be paying healthcare premiums or copays. Yes, they are taking away your health insurance, to give you healthcare, not just taking something away. By casting Medicare For All in a negative light during the debates, the media are supporting special interests and helping to craft policy favorable to those interests. Perhaps, debate viewers, who are concerned about healthcare, may access quality information through the 2021 documentary film, Not Going Quietly.
References:
Graber, Doris A., and Johanna Dunaway. 2018. Mass Media and American Politics. Thousand Oaks, CA: CQ Press.
Using electoral debate questions is a fascinating example of how the media can influence the public's perspective of policy that I hadn't considered, so thank you for covering that angle. I definitely am used to hearing questions about healthcare that are framed with negative language, as if providing health care to citizens is a huge burden instead of a human right. Moderators often use a financial focus that depicts a program like Medicare for All as a detriment to all, rather than a benefit to most. The wording of the questions then leads the audience to believe they should naturally oppose the issue and means that politicians must fight an uphill battle to explain their stance to the public.
ReplyDeleteThis post was so interesting to read! I really liked how you applied the textbook to your post, it really supported your arguments. You taught me that the media controls presidential debates, which I wasn't aware of previously. I think the influence of the media on policies is somewhat toxic. The public can feel like the things in the media are caused by them, but instead it is all influenced by the big corporations, it's kind of scary. Thanks for this post! I learned something new today :)
ReplyDeleteThis post is super interesting! You made a great example of how media companies are extremely influential political actors. Your example of the debates really shines a light of the power that these media companies hold. They can completely carve the direction of political discourse and what can be considered "right" and "wrong". Great Post!
ReplyDelete